OVERLOOKED NEWS

U.S.·United States

Idaho randomly draws Latah and Bannock counties, both of which underreported ballots, for state post-election audits, the Idaho Capital Sun reports

Illustration of an empty, unmarked pale-brick civic building with stone steps and bare autumn trees under an overcast sky; no people, flags, seals or numbers; not a depiction of the Latah County Courthouse or the recount.
Illustration · OVERLOOKED
10O-Score10 · Fully overlooked0 of 13 major U.S. outlets identified in a search-based check (Bing News RSS site: queries, 40-day window), not a live open of each outlet; mapping 0→10. Counts outlets, not source origins. Boise State Public Radio (local NPR member station) is a source, not NPR national, and is not counted. · See proof →
ScoreMeaningMajor U.S. outlets that covered it
10Fully overlooked ← this story0 of 13 outlets
8Barely covered1 outlet
6, 5Lightly covered2 outlets (6) · 3 outlets (5)
4, 3Covered4 outlets (4) · 5 outlets (3)
2, 1, 0Widely covered6–7 outlets (2) · 8–10 outlets (1) · 11–13 outlets (0)

Provisional: Search-based provisional check, 2026-11-09T21:17:52-05:00 to 2026-11-09T21:20:11-05:00 (ET): Bing News RSS site:+keyword queries (4 variants per outlet; ABC on abcnews.go.com and abcnews.com), all 200; candidate headlines regex-filtered then editor-read against a 40-day window. None of the 13 outlet sites was opened live outlet by outlet. Google News was not used. Counts outlets, not origins. Not proof of absence.

Why this is in the archive: We published this on Nov 9, 2026. Regular stories move to the archive 7 days after publishing, so it was moved at 10:25 PM ET on Nov 16, 2026. It was archived for age, not coverage; its O-Score (10) is unchanged. (Not yet logged; the daily recheck will record it.)

Updates

  1. UPDATE (Nov. 15): Latah County and Bannock County, both of which initially underreported ballots in Idaho's Nov. 3 election, have been randomly drawn for state post-election audits, the Idaho Capital Sun reports: “Idaho State Controller Brandon Woolf on Friday plucked numbered tiles representing Latah and Bannock counties out of a bingo-style tumbler.” Friday was Nov. 13. “But the audits aren't targeted,” the Capital Sun reports; they are “required by a 2022 state law” and “are meant to verify the accuracy of election results reported by counties.” Eight counties were drawn: Adams, Bannock, Benewah, Caribou, Gem, Latah, Oneida and Washington. In Bannock County, “officials on Tuesday found 333 ballots that hadn't been counted”; the Capital Sun says those ballots “had been found in a poll volunteer's pickup truck, the local newspaper, the Idaho State Journal, reported.” “The precinct in Bannock that had unreported votes wasn't randomly selected for audits,” and “It's not immediately clear if state election officials will audit the ballots that initially went unreported in Latah and Bannock counties.” In the selected counties, officials are “slated to audit at least 2,100 ballots, or 5% of precincts.” Secretary of State Phil McGrane said of Latah: “I think it was just a misstep, just human error.” The Capital Sun refers to “more than 2,300 ballots” in Latah; this account's figure of 2,342 comes from earlier reports and is unchanged. This update relies on a single source, the Idaho Capital Sun, which cites the Idaho State Journal for the Bannock pickup-truck detail; Overlooked has not seen the Journal's report. Source:
  2. UPDATE (Nov. 13, later): The Latah County commissioners have canvassed the results, the Moscow-Pullman Daily News reports: “The Latah County commissioners made the results of the general election official Thursday by canvassing the votes.” The Daily News reports that “The recount did not change the outcomes of the races” and that “Republicans Tony Johnson and Dan Schoenberg won their respective elections for Latah County Commissioner.” It reports that the Moscow School District levy “passed with 60% of the vote.” County treasurer BJ Swanson said, “I’m sorry, but we failed completely,” and Commissioner Tony Johnson said, “Mistakes happen,” the Daily News reports. Overlooked has not seen the county's minutes or a certified results document. Totals for “federal, state and district candidates” are certified by the state board, which the Capital Sun says “is scheduled to meet Nov. 24.”
  3. UPDATE (Nov. 13): Latah County commissioners were scheduled to canvass the election results on Thursday, Nov. 12. The board's posted agenda lists “Canvass the Votes of the November 3rd Election” at 3 p.m. that day, and the Idaho Press reported that “Final results for the county will be presented for canvass and certification by the Latah County Board of Commissioners on Thursday, Nov. 12.” Overlooked has not confirmed that the canvass took place. When results become official depends on the race. Under Idaho law, “The county board of commissioners shall be the county board of canvassers,” and “Immediately after the general election canvass, the county clerk shall issue a certificate of election to the county candidates who received the highest number of votes”; the Daily News said the commissioners' canvass would “make them official.” Totals for “federal, state and district candidates” are certified by the state board, which the Capital Sun says “is scheduled to meet Nov. 24.” The Idaho Press has reported that “Election results across the state remain unofficial until the state canvass process concludes on Nov. 24.”
  4. UPDATE (Nov. 12): The recount has been held. “The winners of the general election do not appear to have changed in Latah County following a Tuesday recount of the votes,” the Moscow-Pullman Daily News reports, and “Officials recounted all of the county's ballots on Tuesday, not just the unreported ones.” The Idaho Capital Sun reports that the recount “showed that the outcomes of all races and ballot issues in the county remained unchanged, state election officials said,” and that the secretary of state's office “announced the recount was completed early Wednesday morning.” According to “the new unofficial results” reported by the Daily News, Republican Tony Johnson defeated Democrat Carole Wells, 9,213 votes to 8,348, and in the closest commissioner race “Schoenberg won by a slim margin with 8,824 votes to Heinse's 8,695 votes.” “The Latah County Commissioners will canvass these votes on Thursday to make them official,” the Daily News reports; it says the canvass vote “is scheduled for 3 p.m. Thursday” and gives no time zone. Overlooked has not confirmed that the canvass has taken place. Results remain unofficial; the Capital Sun says they “remain unofficial until they are certified by the State Board of Canvassers, which is scheduled to meet Nov. 24.” The sources differ by one ballot: the Daily News gives 2,342, as earlier reports did, while the Capital Sun, citing state election officials, says “2,343 ballots were not added into the state’s system to report unofficial election results on Election Day.” Separately, Spokane Public Radio, in a brief in its Nov. 12 news roundup, reports that “Latah County election workers have finished re-counting more than 18,000 ballots” and that “The Idaho Secretary of State's office says the second canvassing effort didn't bring about any changes from the first election night count.” SPR's reference to “Yesterday's work” is left as written. Source: , ,

Depth

Dig five layers into this story — from what happened to the full picture.

L1What happened

UPDATE (Nov. 13, later): The Latah County commissioners have canvassed the results, the Moscow-Pullman Daily News reports: “The Latah County commissioners made the results of the general election official Thursday by canvassing the votes.” The Daily News reports that “The recount did not change the outcomes of the races” and that “Republicans Tony Johnson and Dan Schoenberg won their respective elections for Latah County Commissioner.” It reports that the Moscow School District levy “passed with 60% of the vote.” County treasurer BJ Swanson said, “I’m sorry, but we failed completely,” and Commissioner Tony Johnson said, “Mistakes happen,” the Daily News reports. Overlooked has not seen the county's minutes or a certified results document. Totals for “federal, state and district candidates” are certified by the state board, which the Capital Sun says “is scheduled to meet Nov. 24.” UPDATE (Nov. 13): Latah County commissioners were scheduled to canvass the election results on Thursday, Nov. 12. The board's posted agenda lists “Canvass the Votes of the November 3rd Election” at 3 p.m. that day, and the Idaho Press reported that “Final results for the county will be presented for canvass and certification by the Latah County Board of Commissioners on Thursday, Nov. 12.” Overlooked has not confirmed that the canvass took place. When results become official depends on the race. Under Idaho law, “The county board of commissioners shall be the county board of canvassers,” and “Immediately after the general election canvass, the county clerk shall issue a certificate of election to the county candidates who received the highest number of votes”; the Daily News said the commissioners' canvass would “make them official.” Totals for “federal, state and district candidates” are certified by the state board, which the Capital Sun says “is scheduled to meet Nov. 24.” The Idaho Press has reported that “Election results across the state remain unofficial until the state canvass process concludes on Nov. 24.” UPDATE (Nov. 12): The recount has been held. “The winners of the general election do not appear to have changed in Latah County following a Tuesday recount of the votes,” the Moscow-Pullman Daily News reports, and “Officials recounted all of the county's ballots on Tuesday, not just the unreported ones.” The Idaho Capital Sun reports that the recount “showed that the outcomes of all races and ballot issues in the county remained unchanged, state election officials said,” and that the secretary of state's office “announced the recount was completed early Wednesday morning.” According to “the new unofficial results” reported by the Daily News, Republican Tony Johnson defeated Democrat Carole Wells, 9,213 votes to 8,348, and in the closest commissioner race “Schoenberg won by a slim margin with 8,824 votes to Heinse's 8,695 votes.” “The Latah County Commissioners will canvass these votes on Thursday to make them official,” the Daily News reports; it says the canvass vote “is scheduled for 3 p.m. Thursday” and gives no time zone. Overlooked has not confirmed that the canvass has taken place. Results remain unofficial; the Capital Sun says they “remain unofficial until they are certified by the State Board of Canvassers, which is scheduled to meet Nov. 24.” The sources differ by one ballot: the Daily News gives 2,342, as earlier reports did, while the Capital Sun, citing state election officials, says “2,343 ballots were not added into the state’s system to report unofficial election results on Election Day.” Separately, Spokane Public Radio, in a brief in its Nov. 12 news roundup, reports that “Latah County election workers have finished re-counting more than 18,000 ballots” and that “The Idaho Secretary of State's office says the second canvassing effort didn't bring about any changes from the first election night count.” SPR's reference to “Yesterday's work” is left as written. Clerk Julie Fry told the Daily News the ballots “were counted on Election Day, but they were not reported online after the results were downloaded onto a USB flash drive.” “Nothing was missing,” she said. “Everything was tabulated. It just wasn't uploaded.” The Moscow School District's seven-year plant facilities levy “is still passing with 60% voter approval,” the Daily News reports; the Capital Sun, citing state election officials, says it “narrowly passed with 60.34% of the vote. It needed 60% support to pass.” Both figures are from unofficial results. Candidate Trish Carter-Goodheart “wants the clerk's office to provide a full report about why the error happened, including a timeline of events,” the Daily News reports. Latah County, Idaho, home to Moscow, will recount all ballots cast in last week's election after 2,342 ballots were left out of the unofficial results it reported publicly, according to the Idaho secretary of state's office. The Spokesman-Review reports that, according to the secretary of state's office, “the review found 2,342 ballots that were counted were not transferred to the county’s election night results reporting system.” The Idaho Capital Sun reports, citing a news release from the same office, that the ballots “were tabulated on the county’s machines but not reported publicly on the county’s election results system”. The recount is scheduled to begin Tuesday, Nov. 10, at 9:30 a.m. at the Latah County Courthouse and is open to the public; it had not taken place when this account was prepared. The Spokesman-Review gives the time without a time zone; the Idaho Capital Sun gives it as “9:30 a.m. Pacific time Tuesday”.

L2Who’s affected

Two findings from the secretary of state's office stand side by side. The Spokesman-Review reports that, according to the office, “an initial review found that the unreported votes did not change any race outcomes.” The same report notes that “the 2,342 votes are within the margin of difference for several local races.” According to The Spokesman-Review, the county has “24,146 registered voters, and 65%, or 15,765 voters, cast ballots in last week’s election”, and both District 6 Idaho House races and the District 6 state Senate race “are within the discrepancy”. The races for two seats on the county commission are “also within 1,000 votes”, and Clerk of the District Court Julie Fry, the county's top election official and a Republican, leads Democratic challenger Shannon May “by 1,289 votes, according to the county’s unofficial election results”, the paper reports. Boise State Public Radio reports that a $65.6 million plant facilities levy shows 62% approval in unofficial results; it needs at least 60%.

L3Why it’s quiet

The outlets describe the discovery differently, and both accounts are shown. The Spokesman-Review, citing the secretary of state's office, says the mistake was discovered by the Latah County Clerk’s Office “during a routine review of election results.” The Idaho Capital Sun, also citing the office, says the clerk's office found it “when it was reviewing election results ahead of the county’s canvass”. Boise State Public Radio reports a third account from County Commissioner Tom Lamar, the commission's only Democrat, who said the clerk's office “on Friday discovered a memory stick containing 2,342 votes that had not been counted.” Lamar's description of the votes as not counted differs from the secretary of state's office, which says they were counted but not reported. Secretary of State Phil McGrane told the station the storage device “was not missing”, and said: “At no point was anything ever missing and it really does appear to be human error in the process”. The office has called it a “procedural error” (The Spokesman-Review). Lamar also told the station that Fry “did not participate in counting the votes herself due to her re-election bid.”

L4Deeper impact

Laura Heinse, a Democratic candidate for county commissioner, “submitted a complaint to McGrane requesting a full recount of ballots cast in her race”, the Idaho Capital Sun reports; unofficial results show her “nearly 200 votes behind Republican Dan Schoenberg”. In the complaint she wrote: “I request a documented timeline establishing when the error was discovered, who knew about it, whether some candidates knew of the error before others, when corrective actions occurred, and why candidates and the public were not promptly informed,” according to the Capital Sun. Fry said in a statement: “We take our responsibility to accurately report election results seriously, and this error should not have happened,” the Capital Sun reports. McGrane said: “Every indication is that the election was conducted properly and a mistake was made when sharing the results publicly.” Idaho Democratic Party Chair Lauren Necochea called the apparent omission “an unacceptable failure that demands immediate answers,” Boise State Public Radio reports.

L5Full context

A note on sourcing: This account relies on The Spokesman-Review (Mitchell Roland, published Nov. 9, 2026, at 2:44 p.m. PT, 5:44 p.m. ET), the Idaho Capital Sun (Kyle Pfannenstiel, published Nov. 9 at 3:32 p.m. MT, 5:32 p.m. ET) and Boise State Public Radio (James Dawson, Nov. 9), a local NPR member station, not NPR's national newsroom. The Capital Sun's headline rounds the figure to 2,300 ballots; all three article bodies give 2,342, which this account uses. When this account was first published, results were unofficial: the Capital Sun reports that they “remain unofficial until they are certified by the State Board of Canvassers, which is scheduled to meet Nov. 24.” Lamar told Boise State Public Radio the recount would delay the county's certification until Thursday afternoon. The recount has since been completed, as the Nov. 12 update reports; for the county and state canvass steps, see the Nov. 13 update. Lamar's account of a memory stick and of Fry's role is his, as reported, and has not been independently verified. Source photos are not used; the image is an illustration.

You’ve reached the bottom. Read the original reporting below.

Summary proof

Summary

UPDATE (Nov. 15): Latah County and Bannock County, both of which initially underreported ballots in Idaho's Nov. 3 election, have been randomly drawn for state post-election audits, the Idaho Capital Sun reports: “Idaho State Controller Brandon Woolf on Friday plucked numbered tiles representing Latah and Bannock counties out of a bingo-style tumbler.” Friday was Nov. 13. “But the audits aren't targeted,” the Capital Sun reports; they are “required by a 2022 state law” and “are meant to verify the accuracy of election results reported by counties.” Eight counties were drawn: Adams, Bannock, Benewah, Caribou, Gem, Latah, Oneida and Washington. In Bannock County, “officials on Tuesday found 333 ballots that hadn't been counted”; the Capital Sun says those ballots “had been found in a poll volunteer's pickup truck, the local newspaper, the Idaho State Journal, reported.” “The precinct in Bannock that had unreported votes wasn't randomly selected for audits,” and “It's not immediately clear if state election officials will audit the ballots that initially went unreported in Latah and Bannock counties.” In the selected counties, officials are “slated to audit at least 2,100 ballots, or 5% of precincts.” Secretary of State Phil McGrane said of Latah: “I think it was just a misstep, just human error.” The Capital Sun refers to “more than 2,300 ballots” in Latah; this account's figure of 2,342 comes from earlier reports and is unchanged. This update relies on a single source, the Idaho Capital Sun, which cites the Idaho State Journal for the Bannock pickup-truck detail; Overlooked has not seen the Journal's report. UPDATE (Nov. 13, later): The Latah County commissioners have canvassed the results, the Moscow-Pullman Daily News reports: “The Latah County commissioners made the results of the general election official Thursday by canvassing the votes.” The Daily News reports that “The recount did not change the outcomes of the races” and that “Republicans Tony Johnson and Dan Schoenberg won their respective elections for Latah County Commissioner.” It reports that the Moscow School District levy “passed with 60% of the vote.” County treasurer BJ Swanson said, “I’m sorry, but we failed completely,” and Commissioner Tony Johnson said, “Mistakes happen,” the Daily News reports. Overlooked has not seen the county's minutes or a certified results document. Totals for “federal, state and district candidates” are certified by the state board, which the Capital Sun says “is scheduled to meet Nov. 24.” UPDATE (Nov. 12): The recount has been held. “The winners of the general election do not appear to have changed in Latah County following a Tuesday recount of the votes,” the Moscow-Pullman Daily News reports, and “Officials recounted all of the county's ballots on Tuesday, not just the unreported ones.” The Idaho Capital Sun reports that the recount “showed that the outcomes of all races and ballot issues in the county remained unchanged, state election officials said,” and that the secretary of state's office “announced the recount was completed early Wednesday morning.” According to “the new unofficial results” reported by the Daily News, Republican Tony Johnson defeated Democrat Carole Wells, 9,213 votes to 8,348, and in the closest commissioner race “Schoenberg won by a slim margin with 8,824 votes to Heinse's 8,695 votes.” “The Latah County Commissioners will canvass these votes on Thursday to make them official,” the Daily News reports; it says the canvass vote “is scheduled for 3 p.m. Thursday” and gives no time zone. Overlooked has not confirmed that the canvass has taken place. Results remain unofficial; the Capital Sun says they “remain unofficial until they are certified by the State Board of Canvassers, which is scheduled to meet Nov. 24.” The sources differ by one ballot: the Daily News gives 2,342, as earlier reports did, while the Capital Sun, citing state election officials, says “2,343 ballots were not added into the state’s system to report unofficial election results on Election Day.” Separately, Spokane Public Radio, in a brief in its Nov. 12 news roundup, reports that “Latah County election workers have finished re-counting more than 18,000 ballots” and that “The Idaho Secretary of State's office says the second canvassing effort didn't bring about any changes from the first election night count.” SPR's reference to “Yesterday's work” is left as written.

Latah County, Idaho, home to Moscow, will recount all ballots cast in last week's election after 2,342 ballots were left out of the unofficial results it reported publicly, according to the Idaho secretary of state's office. The Spokesman-Review reports that, according to the secretary of state's office, “the review found 2,342 ballots that were counted were not transferred to the county’s election night results reporting system.” The Idaho Capital Sun reports, citing a news release from the same office, that the ballots “were tabulated on the county’s machines but not reported publicly on the county’s election results system”. The recount is scheduled to begin Tuesday, Nov. 10, at 9:30 a.m. at the Latah County Courthouse and is open to the public; it had not taken place when this account was prepared. The Spokesman-Review gives the time without a time zone; the Idaho Capital Sun gives it as “9:30 a.m. Pacific time Tuesday”.

Original reporting

  1. Moscow-Pullman Daily News (Anthony Kuipers)Latah County certifies election after recountNov 13, 2026 ↗
  2. Idaho Press (Royce McCandless)Latah County completes full recount, local races unchangedNov 11, 2026 ↗
  3. Latah County Board of Commissioners (posted agenda)Board of Latah County Commissioners formal agenda and schedule of meetings (amended 11/9/2026 9:39 AM)Nov 9, 2026 ↗
  4. Idaho Legislature (Idaho Code)Idaho Code 34-1205. County board of canvassers — MeetingsNov 13, 2026 ↗
  5. Idaho Legislature (Idaho Code)Idaho Code 34-1209. Certificates of election to county candidates after general electionNov 13, 2026 ↗
  6. Idaho Legislature (Idaho Code)Idaho Code 34-1212. Examination and certification of county canvasses by state boardNov 13, 2026 ↗
  7. Idaho Press (Royce McCandless)Latah County conducting full recount after ballot discrepancyNov 9, 2026 ↗
  8. Moscow-Pullman Daily News (Anthony Kuipers)Election outcomes unchanged by recountNov 11, 2026 ↗
  9. Idaho Capital Sun (Kyle Pfannenstiel)After North Idaho’s Latah County found 2,300 of unreported ballots, recount shows no races changedNov 11, 2026 ↗
  10. Spokane Public Radio (SPR News Today roundup brief)SPR News Today: AI and medicine, Dr. Andrew TristerNov 12, 2026 ↗
  11. The Spokesman-ReviewLatah County to conduct full recount after 2,342 ballots were not reported in initial resultsNov 9, 2026 ↗
  12. Idaho Capital SunElection recount planned in North Idaho county that didn’t report 2,300 ballotsNov 9, 2026 ↗
  13. Boise State Public RadioLatah County to conduct full recount after excluding 2,342 votes from resultsNov 9, 2026 ↗
  14. Idaho Capital SunIdaho election officials will audit two counties that underreported votesNov 13, 2026 ↗
Status history (7 events, ET)
  1. O-Score check: 10 (Fully overlooked) · 0 of 13 outlets counted
  2. Published
  3. Update · UPDATE (Nov. 12): The recount has been held. “The winners of the general election do not appear to have changed in Latah County following a Tuesday recount of the votes,” the Moscow-Pullman Daily News reports, and “Officials recounted all o…
  4. Update · UPDATE (Nov. 13): Latah County commissioners were scheduled to canvass the election results on Thursday, Nov. 12. The board's posted agenda lists “Canvass the Votes of the November 3rd Election” at 3 p.m. that day, and the Idaho Press repor…
  5. Update · UPDATE (Nov. 13, later): The Latah County commissioners have canvassed the results, the Moscow-Pullman Daily News reports: “The Latah County commissioners made the results of the general election official Thursday by canvassing the votes.” …
  6. Update · UPDATE (Nov. 15): Latah County and Bannock County, both of which initially underreported ballots in Idaho's Nov. 3 election, have been randomly drawn for state post-election audits, the Idaho Capital Sun reports: “Idaho State Controller Bra…
  7. Moved to the archive (7-day rule) · not yet logged

Story timeline

Drag to see how this story moved: when we published, when big outlets had it, and each O-Score check. From our stored check log; times ET.

Nov 9, 2026Nov 15, 2026

PublishedUpdates 4Outlets by our date 0Later pickups 0Checks 1

No later pickups logged so far.

All 6 events as a list
  1. 9:20 PM ET, Nov 9, 2026 · O-Score check: 0 of 13 outlets had it (score 10)
  2. 10:25 PM ET, Nov 9, 2026 · OVERLOOKED published this story
  3. 3:01 PM ET, Nov 12, 2026 · We updated the story
  4. 2:02 AM ET, Nov 13, 2026 · We updated the story
  5. 4:09 AM ET, Nov 13, 2026 · We updated the story
  6. 11:37 PM ET, Nov 15, 2026 · We updated the story

Trace it: 122 of 122 sourced claims on this page can be traced to the cited source. 122 of 122 have a saved copy of the original report.

IdahoElectionsRecountsElection administrationLocal government

This is an OVERLOOKED summary of the reporting above. Facts and figures come from the linked sources. Everything here is a fact unless it is labelled otherwise. Support this work.

Alerts Get stories like this your way: email, a daily PDF paper, notifications, RSS, or alerts on topics you follow. Choose how →

← Filter all stories