OVERLOOKED NEWS

Asia·Uzbekistan

Four former appeals judges in Tashkent have been convicted in Uzbekistan over a reduced sentence in a high-profile assault and fraud case; one was given four years in prison, and defense lawyers say judges have all but stopped acquitting

Illustration: fallen chinar leaves floating on still, dark water.
Illustration · OVERLOOKED
10O-Score10 · Fully overlooked0 of 13 major U.S. outlets identified in a search-based check (WebSearch topic query plus 13-outlet site-batch queries, about 4:46-4:50 PM ET, Nov. 18, 2026), not a live open of each outlet's own search; mapping 0→10, 1→8, 2→6, 3→5, 4→4. Counts outlets, not source origins: none found. Cited outlets only. · See proof →
ScoreMeaningMajor U.S. outlets that covered it
10Fully overlooked ← this story0 of 13 outlets
8Barely covered1 outlet
6, 5Lightly covered2 outlets (6) · 3 outlets (5)
4, 3Covered4 outlets (4) · 5 outlets (3)
2, 1, 0Widely covered6–7 outlets (2) · 8–10 outlets (1) · 11–13 outlets (0)

Provisional: Search-based provisional check about 4:46-4:50 PM ET, Nov. 18, 2026: outlets were checked by WebSearch topic and 13-outlet site-batch queries, not by opening each outlet's own site search; search-index coverage of the last 24-48 hours is incomplete; absence among the 13 is not proof of absence. Coverage of the Nov. 13 verdict was found in Eurasianet, Gazeta.uz, UzDaily, Uzbekistan Observer and tafs.uz; none is among the 13. Among the 13, search returned only older, unrelated Uzbekistan court items; not counted.

Depth

Dig five layers into this story — from what happened to the full picture.

L1What happened

What happened: The case turned on Akmal Shukurov. According to Eurasianet, a three-judge panel of the Tashkent City Court made up of Turgunova, Abidov and Ilkhomjonov "heard the case December 9, 2025, and reduced Shukurov's sentence to four years and a month of restricted liberty." Eurasianet reports that "On December 18, a review panel of the Tashkent City Court took the case back up, canceled the sentence and put Shukurov back in prison." On Jan. 12, officers from the General Prosecutor's Office searched the judges' homes, arrested them and charged them, according to Turgunova's letter to the UN as reported by Eurasianet. Gazeta.uz says the three panel judges were convicted under part 1 of Article 231 of the Criminal Code: "вынесение неправосудного приговора" — delivering an unjust verdict (our translation).

L2Who’s affected

Who is affected: The four former judges, who can appeal; Abdulmalik Abdullayev, an attorney for Turgunova, said his client would appeal, Eurasianet reports. "Осуждённые имеют право подать апелляционную или кассационную жалобу на решение суда." — The convicted have the right to file an appeal or cassation complaint against the court's decision (our translation), Gazeta.uz reports. The defense argues the verdict reaches every judge in the country: Abdullayev told Eurasianet the case "sends a signal to every current judge about the risks that they can run when making judicial decisions". Defense attorney and former judge Mukhsinjon Madaminov said: "We've gone backward. We've strayed from Mirziyoyev's path."

L3Why it’s quiet

Why it stayed quiet: Analysis: this is a domestic court case in Central Asia, reported in English by Eurasianet and in Russian and Uzbek by local outlets such as Gazeta.uz. Eurasianet says the General Prosecutor's Office referred its request for comment on the verdict to the Supreme Court, "which did not respond." A search-based check of 13 major U.S. outlets found none that had reported it.

L4Deeper impact

Deeper impact: Eurasianet reports that UN officials have flagged "unjust decision" statutes as a threat to Uzbekistan's judicial independence because they "effectively give prosecutors the ability to go after judges who rule against them." In a July 2026 letter to the UN's High Commissioner for Human Rights, Turgunova wrote that officials "forced us through pressure and threats to sign explanatory letters as if the decision had been made on the instructions of" Mirzajonov, Eurasianet reports. Prosecutors told a different story: according to an investigative summary obtained by Eurasianet, the panel first intended to cut the sentence to a little more than three years in prison, and prosecutors alleged that Mirzajonov insisted on four years of restricted liberty. Eurasianet could not reach Mirzajonov's attorneys; in a prosecutors' summary of his January 2026 interrogation, he said he discussed the case informally with the panel judges but did not tell them how to rule.

L5Full context

Full context: "Security camera footage showed Shukurov assaulting a man outside a swanky downtown Tashkent hotel in March of that year", Eurasianet reports. Accounts of his first sentence differ slightly: Eurasianet says a district court "sentenced him to eight years in prison in October 2025"; Gazeta.uz says that on Oct. 24, 2025, he received "8 лет и 1 месяц лишения свободы" — 8 years and 1 month of imprisonment (our translation). Gazeta.uz reports that the Dec. 18 review panel "вновь назначила Акмалю Шукурову лишение свободы сроком на 6 лет" — again sentenced Akmal Shukurov to 6 years of imprisonment (our translation). Abdullayev told Eurasianet that the four were found not guilty on charges tied to cases other than Shukurov's.

You’ve reached the bottom. Read the original reporting below.

Summary proof

Summary

A court in Uzbekistan has convicted four former appeals judges over their ruling that cut the sentence of a man convicted in a high-profile assault and fraud case, Eurasianet reports. Murodjon Mirzajonov, "the ex-deputy chief judge of the Tashkent City Court, was found guilty November 13" of "interference in an investigation or judicial decision" and "received a four-year prison sentence." The other three, Mukhtarama Turgunova, Mirziyod Abidov and Odilbek Ilkhomjonov, "were sentenced to four years of restricted liberty", according to Eurasianet. Gazeta.uz, citing the press service of the regional courts, reports that all four were also barred for three years from judicial posts: "с лишением на 3 года права занимать должности, связанные с осуществлением должностных полномочий в судебной системе" — with deprivation for 3 years of the right to hold posts involving official powers in the judicial system (our translation).

The two outlets differ on which court ruled. Eurasianet says "A district court has convicted four former appeals court judges"; Gazeta.uz says: "13 ноября Ташкентский областной суд вынес приговор по уголовному делу" — On Nov. 13, the Tashkent Regional Court delivered a verdict in the criminal case (our translation). Gazeta.uz identifies the former deputy court chairman only by the initials "М. М." Defense attorneys told Eurasianet on Nov. 18 "that judges across the country have all but stopped acquitting defendants for fear that they too may be prosecuted." Prosecutors say they were protecting the reforms: prosecutor Aziz Khanberdiyev said in his closing argument that the man's release "led to serious consequences, such as serious damage to the reputation of the judicial and legal reforms being carried out by the state", Eurasianet reports.

Original reporting

  1. Eurasianet (Alexander Thompson)Uzbekistan's judicial reforms on trial: Four judges convicted for "unjust decision"Nov 18, 2026 ↗
  2. Gazeta.uz (in Russian)Бывшим судьям, смягчившим наказание Акмалю Шукурову, вынесли приговор (Former judges who softened Akmal Shukurov's sentence have been sentenced; our translation)Nov 14, 2026 ↗
Status history (2 events, ET)
  1. O-Score check: 10 (Fully overlooked) · of 13 outlets counted
  2. Published

Story timeline

Drag to see how this story moved: when we published, when big outlets had it, and each O-Score check. From our stored check log; times ET.

Nov 18, 2026Nov 18, 2026

PublishedUpdates 0Outlets by our date 0Later pickups 0Checks 1

No later pickups logged so far.

All 2 events as a list
  1. 4:50 PM ET, Nov 18, 2026 · O-Score check: of 13 outlets had it (score 10)
  2. 5:27 PM ET, Nov 18, 2026 · OVERLOOKED published this story

Trace it: 24 of 24 sourced claims on this page can be traced to the cited source. 24 of 24 have a saved copy of the original report.

UzbekistanCourtsJudicial independenceRule of lawProsecution of judges

This is an OVERLOOKED summary of the reporting above. Facts and figures come from the linked sources. Everything here is a fact unless it is labelled otherwise. Support this work.

Alerts Get stories like this your way: email, a daily PDF paper, notifications, RSS, or alerts on topics you follow. Choose how →

← Filter all stories